iHome iSP8 vs iDevices Switch – Which Smart Plug is Better?

Design

The size of the plug is important to us. Why? Because larger plugs will block the second outlet making it useless. Neither the iSP8 or Switch will block the plug in any configuration so you could have two smart plugs in a regular outlet. We can’t say this for the other plugs that we’ve reviewed (like the KooGeek SmartPlug and Incipio CommandKit).

The only other difference between the plugs is the location of the outlet as the iDevices Switch has the outlet on the edge of the plug rather than the middle. This is an important design difference as it reduces the footprint of the device which is why we like the iDevices Switch in the bedroom and/or bathroom. A downside of this particular design is that it doesn’t work with outlets parallel to the ground.

Accessing the power button is another design feature that we’ll rate for. Why? Because there will instances where it is easier to turn the plug off manually then using your smartphone. The average smart switch will have a power button the size of an iPhone home button which is harder to access when compared to the iSP8 and Switch.

Functionality

We didn’t have any issues accessing the units through Apple’s Home App or through the other HomeKit enabled apps. The iHome and iDevices app didn’t offer anything out of the ordinary. Neither app stood out to us like the Elgato Eve app did.

When it comes to overall functionality, the iHome iSP8 edges out the iDevices Switch because you can access the iSP8 remotely without having to use an iPad or Apple TV for HomeKit. This added functionality requires you to create an iHome account which isn’t great if you don’t mind signing up with another service/website.

Both smart plugs run only on 2.4Ghz WiFi which is an issue for some who only use 5Ghz. The last thing we noticed during our usage period was the Switch running into issues when treated as a mobile plug. Moving the plug around resulted in the unit being rested which had to be re-added back to the network.

Both products allow you to measure the power consumption of the appliance plugged in which is handy for larger, power hungry devices like dehumidifiers and air-conditioners.

For compatibility, both plugs aren’t IFTTT enabled which is a bummer. After that, the biggest difference is the lack of connectivity the iDevices Switch has with SmartThings and Wink. Both products will work with HomeKit, Alexa as well as Google Home.

Extras

When it comes to extra features, the iSP8 comes with a remote which is handy if you’re using your smart plug with an appliance that’s hard to reach or if you don’t always have your smartphone or tablet on you. The cherry on top is the fact that the remote doesn’t require line of sight and will work up to 35 ft away. However, the remote is also another thing to lose as we still can’t find ours.

The iDevice Switch comes with a coloured night light. The color of the light can be customized and the night light is treated as it’s own accessory. Comparing the extra features from both smart plugs, we’d say that the night light is more useful. The combination of the side outlet and night light make the Switch the best smart plug in a bedroom/bathroom setting.

Do you have any question in our iHome iSP8 vs iDevices Switch comparison? Please ask them below!