| KooGeek Smart Plug P1 | Incipio CommandKit Smart Outlet | Elgato Eve Energy | |
 |  |  | |
| Header | (out of 5) | (out of 5) | (out of 5) |
| Review Link | |||
| Price | Price: 29.99 USD | Price: 39.95 USD | Price: 49.95 USD |
| Top Buy Button |  |  | |
| Pros | Pros: – One of the cheapest smart plugs | Pros: – Free’s up an outlet if used on the bottom outlet – Tracks energy usage | Pros: – Elgato’s App is top notch – Works well with larger appliances (i.e. dehumidifier) |
| Cons | Cons: – Large – Energy metering info is hard to access in app – Apple Watch app isn’t user friendly | Cons: – Small manual button – Large – CommandKit App doesn’t look as polished | Cons: – “Slower” than other plugs (by a second) – Fairly large |
| Design/Functionality Rating | DESIGN & FUNCTIONALITY (KooGeek Smart Plug) | DESIGN & FUNCTIONALITY (Incipio CommandKit Smart Outlet) | DESIGN & FUNCTIONALITY (Elgato Eve Energy) |
| Design/Functionality | – Blocks second outlet – Manual button is small – Basic app – No connectivity issues – No remote access (without Apple TV) – Apple Watch integration is tough to use – Energy metering info is tough to access – No extra features | – Blocks second outlet (if used on top outlet) – Manual buttons is small – App is nothing special – No connectivity issues – No remote access (without Apple TV) – No Apple Watch integration – Energy metering – No extra features | – Blocks second outlet – Manual button is small – App is one of the best for HomeKit – Uses Bluetooth rather than WiFi – No remote access (without Apple TV) – No Apple Watch integration – Energy metering – No extra features |
| Compatibility Rating | COMPATIBILITY | COMPATIBILITY | COMPATIBILITY |
| Compatibility | Works with: -HomeKit Doesn’t work with: – Amazon Alexa – Wink – Google Home – Samsung Smart Things – IFTTT | Works with: -HomeKit Doesn’t work with: – Amazon Alexa – Wink – Google Home – Samsung Smart Things – IFTTT | Works with: -HomeKit Doesn’t work with: – Amazon Alexa – Wink – Google Home – Samsung Smart Things – IFTTT |
| Bottom Buy Button | | | |
